Common NameWestern Kingbird
Scientific NameTyrannus verticalis
Type of ReportRare Species
Date of Observation10/03/2020
Number Observed1
Reporting Observer's NameKyle Jones
Mailing Address230 South Windsor St
South Royalton, VT 05068
United States
Map It
EmailEmail hidden; Javascript is required.
Date Completed10/16/2020
Names & Emails of Other Contributing Observers

Also seen on both occasions by Elisabeth (Tii) McLane.
Photos are in the checklists.

Latitude of Observation (enter 0 if unable to provide)0
Longitude of Observation (enter 0 if unable to provide)0
Place NameCampbell Flats
TownshipNorwich
CountyWindsor
Vermont eBird Checklist URLebird.org
Time of Day09:00 AM
Length of Time Observed20 minutes
Maximum Estimated Distance from Bird (in feet)200
Minimum Estimated Distance from Bird (in feet)100
Noteworthy Weather Conditions

It's been a while, but I recall good light, or at least light in our favor, and no precip or wind.

Optical Equipment Used for Observation

8x binoculars

Observer’s Previous Acquaintance With This or Similar Species

Seen in many N.A. locations, including as a vagrant on the east coast on several occasions. I have also seen most (all?) of the similar N.A. species.

I certify that any attachments included with this report were captured during this observation event​​.
Description of Habitat

Roadside. Lightly travelled road with a cornfield, hayfield, and a few residences in the area.

Behaviors Observed

When observed it was mostly perched high in trees. Both in a small snag or a large oak tree.

Description of Vocalizations

None heard.

Verbal Narrative & Description of Observation

Tii first saw the bird and described to me she had seen a bird with a yellow belly and white outer tail feathers sitting high in a tree. I said something like: "I need to see that bird". We soon relocated the bird and it was clearly a medium-sized flycatcher, trending towards kingbird. I initially thought it was a western kingbird but wanted to rule out other similar (but also vagrant) species. We had the chance for some decent close looks, but I did not have a camera or scope with me, so grabbed a few phone shots through my binoculars (in checklist). Eventually I got to the car and retrieved my spotting scope digiscope photos, but as I was setting up the bird flew away and was not relocated. Tii and I came back 2 days later and relocated the bird in the same area. After that many observers had a chance to see it over a period of a few days.

Relative Size & Shape

Kingbird size and shape and behavior (ruling out Myiarchus spp).

Head

Light gray head with pale chin and throat. Thin black mask.

Feet & Bill

Small dark bill. Feet details not noted.

Upper Back

Vague on this but darkish, not yellow.

Lower Back & Rump

Same as upper back.

Wings

Not noted at the time.

Breast, Belly, Flanks, Under Tail Coverts

Bright yellow flanks and belly. I would have said the breast was yellow too (from memory) but looking at images from the second sighting that was clearly not the case.

Tail

Typical kingbird tail but clearly with bold white outer tail feathers ruling out other species of flycatcher.

IMPORTANT: What similar species were eliminated when making the identification and how was this bird different?

Cassin's Kingbird was considered but rejected when the bold white outer tail feathers were seen. I had not considered Tropical or Couch's Kingbird at the time but the white outer tail feathers also ruled out those species. The smallish bill and white outer tail feathers rule out Loggerhead Kingbird.

Other Notes & Comments

Age and sex not determined.
Relocated and photographed again on October 5.
https://ebird.org/vt/checklist/S74452950
Seen and photographed by many observers after the second observation.

This report was written from notes taken:Written from Memory